Part 3 of the 2012 RotationRater lays out each operation’s rotation and grades it based on the RotationRater system described (in great detail) over the last two posts. There will be a brief Part 4 as I had entry issues converting the spreadsheet to the webpage, so there is little to no commentary below. By Tuesday, there will be some notes on Acreage comparisons to last year and a few more notes on how the Penalties were calculated and why and how the Score was weighted.
The Net Return data from Component #1 is re-printed here and it is followed by each J-MAS client’s rotation (anonymously) and Graded based on a weighted scoring system.
Rotation Rater Marketing #3 – Final Net Return per Acre and ROI
|
pre-Modified |
J-MAS RR |
J-MAS RR |
|
|
|
Net Return |
Modifier |
Net Return |
J-MAS RR |
|
|
per Acre |
Total |
per Acre |
ROI |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Durum |
$46.08 |
$16.92 |
$63.00 |
30.4% |
|
Sp. Wheat |
$32.12 |
$7.66 |
$39.78 |
19.3% |
|
W. Wheat |
$67.13 |
$11.66 |
$78.79 |
39.0% |
|
Malt Barley |
$76.51 |
-$14.56 |
$61.95 |
29.4% |
|
Feed Barley |
$49.60 |
$8.71 |
$58.31 |
30.7% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Yellow Pea |
$49.45 |
$12.64 |
$62.09 |
30.6% |
|
Green Pea |
$57.14 |
$0.34 |
$57.48 |
28.0% |
|
Lg. Gr. Lentil |
$74.08 |
-$10.71 |
$63.37 |
24.0% |
|
Md. Gr. Lentil |
$71.53 |
-$8.45 |
$63.08 |
23.9% |
|
Red Lentil |
$34.80 |
$3.54 |
$38.34 |
14.7% |
|
K. Chickpea |
$214.76 |
-$85.89 |
$128.87 |
32.0% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Canola |
$91.98 |
$18.22 |
$110.20 |
40.0% |
|
Flax |
$67.09 |
$9.91 |
$77.00 |
36.7% |
|
Mustard |
$74.92 |
-$4.24 |
$70.68 |
32.4% |
|
xx
Perfect Rotation – Weighted Score = 91.6% A++
Durum 13%, W.Wheat 20%, Yellow Pea 8%, K.Chickpea 25%, Canola 34%
Cereal = 33%, Pulse = 33%, Oilseed = 34%
Net Return per Acre = $98.60 Rotation Cost = $277.55 ROI =35.8%
Agronomic Penalties: 0% Rotation Penalties: 0% Marketing Penalties: 0%
xx
Operation #1 – Weighted Score = 88.8% A+
Durum 24%, W.Wheat 8%, K.Chickpea 33%, Canola 35%
Cereal = 32%, Pulse = 33%, Oilseed = 35%
Net Return per Acre = $102.53 Rotation Cost = $294.51 ROI =35.1%
Agronomic Penalties: 0% Rotation Penalties: –4% (Chickpea >25%) Marketing Penalties: 0%
xx
Operation #2 – Weighted Score = 85.8% A+
Durum 20%, W.Wheat 16%, LG.Lentil 16%, K.Chickpea 20%, Canola 29%
Cereal = 36%, Pulse = 36%, Oilseed = 34%
Net Return per Acre = $92.31 Rotation Cost = $273.69 ROI =33.9%
Agronomic Penalties: 0% Rotation Penalties: 0% Marketing Penalties: 0%
xx
Operation #3 – Weighted Score = 84.3% A
Durum 42%, K.Chickpea 17%, Canola 42%
Cereal = 42%, Pulse = 17%, Oilseed = 42%
Net Return per Acre = $92.20 Rotation Cost = $267.83 ROI =34.7%
Agronomic Penalties: -2% (Any Crop >40%) Rotation Penalties: 0% Marketing Penalties: -2% (Less than 4 Crops)
xx
Operation #4 – Weighted Score = 80.3% A
Durum 39%, LG.Lentil 18%, K.Chickpea 10%, Canola 24%
Cereal = 39%, Pulse = 28%, Oilseed = 24%
Net Return per Acre = $86.38 Rotation Cost = $269.53 ROI =31.8%
Agronomic Penalties: 0% Rotation Penalties: 0% Marketing Penalties: 0%
xx
Operation #5 – Weighted Score = 78.2% B+
Durum 31%, LG.Lentil 30%, K.Chickpea 10%, Canola 29%
Cereal = 31%, Pulse = 40%, Oilseed = 29%
Net Return per Acre = $83.30 Rotation Cost = $263.49 ROI =31.4%
Agronomic Penalties: 0% Rotation Penalties: 0% Marketing Penalties: 0%
xx
Operation #6 – Weighted Score = 75.7% B+
Durum 48%, LG.Lentil 12%, K.Chickpea 19%, Canola 20%
Cereal = 48%, Pulse = 31%, Oilseed = 20%
Net Return per Acre = $85.28 Rotation Cost = $265.22 ROI =31.9%
Agronomic Penalties: -4% (Any Crop >40%) Rotation Penalties: 0% Marketing Penalties: 0%
xx
Operation #7 – Weighted Score = 74.7% B
Durum 32%, Fd.Barley 7%, Y.Pea 15%, LG.Lentil 10%, K.Chickpea 4%, Canola 31%
Cereal = 39%, Pulse = 29%, Oilseed = 31%
Net Return per Acre = $79.94 Rotation Cost = $240.50 ROI =32.8%
Agronomic Penalties: 0% Rotation Penalties: 0% Marketing Penalties: 0%
xx
Operation #8 – Weighted Score = 71.7% B
Durum 42%, Y.Pea 5%, LG.Lentil 22%, K.Chickpea 4%, Canola 26%
Cereal = 42%, Pulse = 31%, Oilseed = 26%
Net Return per Acre = $78.02 Rotation Cost = $244.99 ROI =31.6%
Agronomic Penalties: -1% (Any Crop >40%) Rotation Penalties: 0% Marketing Penalties: 0%
xx
Operation #9 – Weighted Score = 71.5% D+
Durum 54%, LG.Lentil 25%, K.Chickpea 11%, Canola 11%
Cereal = 54%, Pulse = 36%, Oilseed = 11%
Net Return per Acre = $75.03 Rotation Cost = $248.88 ROI =30.0%
Agronomic Penalties: -7% (Crop >40%) Rotation Penalties: -7% (Class >50% & <20%) Marketing Penalties: 0%
xx
Operation #10 – Weighted Score = 70.9% B
Durum 18%, Sp.Wheat 13%, Fd.Barley 5%, Y.Pea 14%, LG.Lentil 16%, K.Chickpea 6%, Canola 29%
Cereal = 36%, Pulse = 36%, Oilseed = 29%
Net Return per Acre = $77.18 Rotation Cost = $245.59 ROI =30.9%
Agronomic Penalties: 0% Rotation Penalties: 1% (>6 Crops) Marketing Penalties: 0%
xx
Operation #11 – Weighted Score = 70.6% B
Durum 37%, Y.Pea 21%, LG.Lentil 13%, Canola 28%
Cereal = 37%, Pulse = 34%, Oilseed = 28%
Net Return per Acre = $76.11 Rotation Cost = $232.9 ROI =32.3%
Agronomic Penalties: 0% Rotation Penalties: 0% Marketing Penalties: 0%
xx
Operation #12 – Weighted Score = 67.2% C+
Durum 29%, Sp.Wheat 15%, Y.Pea 7%, LG.Lentil 14%, K.Chickpea 12%, Canola 15%, Flax 7%
Cereal = 44%, Pulse = 33%, Oilseed = 22%
Net Return per Acre = $73.45 Rotation Cost = $247.74 ROI =29.3%
Agronomic Penalties: 0% Rotation Penalties: -1% (>6 Crops) Marketing Penalties: 0%
xx
Operation #13 – Weighted Score = 66.7% C+
Durum 44%, W.Wheat 9%, LG.Lentil 24%, Canola 24%
Cereal = 53%, Pulse = 24%, Oilseed = 24%
Net Return per Acre = $75.56 Rotation Cost = $236.04 ROI =31.9%
Agronomic Penalties: -2% (Crop >40%) Rotation Penalties: -1% (Class >50%) Marketing Penalties: 0%
xx
Operation #14 – Weighted Score = 66.2% C+
Durum 47%, LG.Lentil 24%, Canola 29%
Cereal = 47%, Pulse = 24%, Oilseed = 29%
Net Return per Acre = $76.97 Rotation Cost = $240.41 ROI = 31.8%
Agronomic Penalties: -4% (Crop >40%) Rotation Penalties: 0% Marketing Penalties: 0%
xx
Operation #15 – Weighted Score = 63.8% C
Durum 25%, Sp.Wheat 11%, Y.Pea 24%, LG.Lentil 7%, Canola 15%, Flax 18%
Cereal = 36%, Pulse = 31%, Oilseed = 33%
Net Return per Acre = $69.80 Rotation Cost = $220.50 ROI = 31.4%
Agronomic Penalties: 0% Rotation Penalties: 0% Marketing Penalties: 0%
xx
Operation #16 – Weighted Score = 62.1% C
Durum 52%, LG.Lentil 15%, Canola 33%
Cereal = 52%, Pulse = 15%, Oilseed = 33%
Net Return per Acre = $78.79 Rotation Cost = $238.11 ROI =32.7%
Agronomic Penalties: -6% (Crop >40%) Rotation Penalties: -4% (Class >50% & <20%) Marketing Penalties: –2% (<4 Crops)
xx
Operation #17 – Weighted Score = 56.2% D+
Durum 54%, LG.Lentil 25%, K.Chickpea 11%, Canola 11%
Cereal = 54%, Pulse = 36%, Oilseed = 11%
Net Return per Acre = $75.03 Rotation Cost = $248.88 ROI =30.0%
Agronomic Penalties: -7% (Crop >40%) Rotation Penalties: -7% (Class >50% & <20%) Marketing Penalties: 0%
xx
Operation #18 – Weighted Score = 55.1% D+
Durum 46%, Fd.Barley 10%, LG.Lentil 28%, K.Chickpea 4%, Canola 11%
Cereal = 56%, Pulse = 32%, Oilseed = 11%
Net Return per Acre = $70.71 Rotation Cost = $237.24 ROI = 29.8%
Agronomic Penalties: -3% (Crop >40%) Rotation Penalties: -7% (Class >50% & <20%) Marketing Penalties: 0%
xx
Operation #19 – Weighted Score = 36.9% F
Durum 44%, Y.Pea 56%
Cereal = 44%, Pulse = 56%, Oilseed = 0%
Net Return per Acre = $79.85 Rotation Cost = $234.29 ROI =34.41%
Agronomic Penalties: -2% (Crop >40%) Rotation Penalties: -13% (Class >50% & 20%) Marketing Penalties: -4% (<4 Crops)
Like this:
Like Loading...